The Define phase (DMAIC) is the first phase of Six Sigma improvement process and it is critical to Six Sigma’s success. As the name indicates Define is all about describing the problem and setting the project goal.

Six Sigma Phases

Six Sigma is a systematic problem solving approach that is centered around defects elimination and variation reduction which leads to process improvement.

One of the principal tools in Six Sigma is the use of the DMAIC methodology. (Also see DMAIC Overview). Particularly, DMAIC is a logical framework that helps you think through and plan improvements to a process in pursuit of achieving a Six Sigma level of excellence. Five phases of DMAIC method.

Use the Define Phase of DMAIC to qualify a project to see if it is worth doing, if it is a good fit for the Six Sigma approach, and to set the stage for the project.

Like a good reporter, learn the background of what is being asked and focus on the 5Ws – Who, What, When, Where, and Why. This becomes evident when you use the tools below to identify scope, goals, and rationale.

Goals of Define Phase

  • Understand the project, including its purpose and scope.
  • Determine whether the process is a good candidate for DMAIC.
  • Map the current process.
  • Detail customer expectations.
  • Estimate timelines and costs using project management tools

DMAIC Define Phase Overview

The Define phase is approximately 2 to 3 weeks process based on the project inputs and begins with the selection of project champion.

The define phase is all about establishing the project therefore many individual activities to complete. There are multiple tools and concepts available in Define phase of six sigma.

Project Basics

What is Quality –The ASQ defines it like this:

A subjective term for which each person or sector has its own definition. In technical usage, quality can have two meanings: 1) the characteristics of a product or service that bear on its ability to satisfy stated or implied needs; 2) a product or service free of deficiencies. According to Joseph Juran, quality means “fitness for use”; according to Philip Crosby, it means “conformance to requirements.”ASQ Quality Glossary

Cost of Poor Quality: Cost of Poor Quality (CoPQ) is defined as the cost associated with providing poor Quality products or services. It is basically combination of preventive costs, appraisal costs, Internal failure costs, and external failure costs.

CTQ requirements: Critical requirements on process outputs and other critical process performance measures are called CTQ. Critical to Quality requirements relate to customer expectations and needs around the quality of the output.

Causal Theory y=f(x): Causal theory, in Six Sigma terms, means that you create output (y) from an input (x) and a function (f)

Process performance metrics

There are many process performance metrics that we can use to measure the current and future value of our processes.

Defects per Opportunity (DPO): DPO stands for Defects per opportunity. This is a simple ratio. Take the number of defects you have in your process (usually found by sampling) and divide it by however many opportunities there are. 

Defects per Unit (DPU): Defects per unit is a similar calculation to DPO, but instead of looking at opportunities, we’re looking at units. 

Defects per Million Opportunities (DPMO):DPMO is based on DPO, but in real-world manufacturing type numbers. This is an important metric, because it’s used in Six Sigma to measure the performance of a process. If you’ve already worked out DPO for a sample, you can calculate DPMO by simply multiplying the decimal result (not the percentage) by one million.

First-Time Yield (FTY): First-time yield is the most common way to calculate the process yield. It is the number of defect-free units coming out of a process, compared to the number of units manufactured. In other words, it is the probability of a defect-free output from a process.

Rolled Throughput Yield (RTY): RTY provides a probability that a unit will be generated by a process with no defects. In other words, it’s the probability that a multi-step process will produce a defect-free unit.

Lean Metrics

Lean metrics are the measures that can be used to control and monitor the manufacturing processes such that continuous quality can be facilitated by identifying the opportunities for improvements and changes.

Cycle time: Cycle time is the average time taken to complete a process, per item. It is calculated as the reciprocal of the throughput rate. In other words:

Total Lead Time: Lead time is the total time taken for the work to process from one point to another in the manufacturing process. It is calculated the time between two points, known as starting point and end point. 

Process Cycle Efficiency: The process cycle efficiency helps to detect how much of the process is actually adding value to the entire process.

Project Selection

Select a project with needs and criteria that are appropriate for using DMAIC. The problem could be anything that impact the Key performance Indicator (KPI) like process output, customer satisfaction, production cost, defects, rework, cycle time etc.

Project Cost/Benefit Analysis (CBA): Cost/Benefits analysis involves looking at the projected costs and returns of a project. It gives us data that we need to decide whether a project is worth doing.

Cost of Poor Quality: Cost of Poor Quality (CoPQ) is defined as the cost associated with providing poor Quality products or services. It is basically combination of preventive costs, appraisal costs, Internal failure costs, and external failure costs.

Project Charter: A process charter is a high level document that provide purpose and motivation for the initiative, serves as a working document for the team and as a reference for the rest of the company. Project charter is the most important document in Define phase of six sigma and that will be updated throughout the DMAIC process.

A Project Charter should contain following elements

  • Business case
  • Problem statement
  • Project scope
  • Goal statement
  • Milestone/Deliverables
  • Resources

Organizations use various tools to make their goals achievable. SMART (Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic and Time Bound) is a technique helps to attain and track the project goals.

Current State Process Analysis

SIPOC: A SIPOC is a high-level process mapping tool to help visualize a process and its influences. In other words, it is a useful tool that depicts how a process serves the customer and summarizes inputs and outputs of a process in a visual format. 

Flow chart: A process flowchart is a simple process map that provides the visual representation of the sequence of activities along with their points of decisions. These flowcharts provide the basic details of the process, which can later be augmented by adding the roles of different staffs.

Swim Lane Flow Chart: These process maps provide the interactions between different departments and the roles performed by different people in the organization. Also termed as ‘swim- lane’ charts, these process maps have vertical lines showing the movement of process from person to person.

Input-Output (IPO) Model : Measurement of process inputs and outputs can be used to optimize the process being measured. Inputs may be raw material, resources etc and out puts are the end products.

Identify Voice of Customer (VOC)

An understating of customer needs is critical for business success. It is necessary for business to constantly in contact with customers. Collecting voice customer is a multi-level task. Below are the tools to get Voice of Client in a effective way.

  • Reactive
    • Complaint logs
    • Hotlines
    • Tech support calls
    • Website activity
  • Proactive
    • Focus Groups
    • Interviews
    • Surveys
    • Comment cards
    • Marketing research
    • Observation: “Go to the Gemba”

Analyze VOC

Kano Diagrams: The Kano model is a framework to prioritize features based on the degree to which they will satisfy or delighted the users. In other words, a model that helps to prioritize the features based on how much that feature will delight the users.

CTQ requirements: Critical to Quality requirements relate to customer expectations and needs around the quality of the output.

The Pareto Chart is a graphical tool to map and grade business process problems from the most recurrent to the least frequent. In other words, this helps to identify the most frequently occurring problems or separate the vital few from the trivial many.

Critical-to-Quality Tree: A Critical to Quality Tree (CTQ Tree) reflects what the consumers of your process cite as absolutely essential to success. This helps to clarify what is a defect in the process. It also helps to distinguish what your client’s needs vs what their requirements are.

House of Quality: Quality Function Deployment (QFD) is a planning process for products and services that starts with the voice of the customer. Quality Function Deployment (QFD) is a structured approach for defining customer requirements and translating design specifications or product control characteristics in the form of a planning matrix

Project Management

In Six Sigma project management, senior managers take an active role. They create projects by choosing a business process that is in need of improvement. However, a project manager – often a Six Sigma Black Belt – will usually lead the project itself.

There are three basic stages in Six Sigma project management:

  • Planning: You work out what needs to be done to make the project a success.
  • Scheduling: You map out how much time it will take your team to complete all the tasks.
  • Controlling: You keep track of both of these factors throughout the project, and adapt resources, planning, or scheduling so that it stays on track.

Project management tools act as an aid to an individual as well as a team for better project management irrespective of the project size. For effective project management, the organization or project management team should have appropriate tools. The project management tools help to standardize the work and make the project manager work efficiently. 

Six Sigma Teams

Team dynamics refers to the force that inspires or drives a group of people to work collectively for a common cause or objective. A good team is a team with different personalities and also a common identity.

We use Stakeholder Analysis to identify people who have a stake in our product. We use stakeholder analysis before we start planning a project. Why? Because we need to know who we need to be talking to and what we’ll need from them. Until we have that, we can’t create an effective plan. And we also need to plan our output. This affects what we’ll put into updates and when.

When you put together a Six Sigma team, you want to merge individuals into a cohesive team that will work together. Understanding the stages of team growth can help you to fast-track that process, and keep it from derailing.

Summary of the Stages of Team Growth

According to Bruce Tuckman, there are five basic stages in a team’s evolution:

  • Forming: Team members get to know each other and look for roles within the team.
  • Storming: The team get used to each other, and start to disagree and have conflicts.
  • Norming: Team members accept their roles and begin to feel like a cohesive team.
  • Performing: The team can both reach consensus and act on that consensus as a group.
  • Transforming: The team is breaking up because the project is nearly or completely ended.

Roles of Six Sigma Teams

There are a lot of potential roles in a Six Sigma team. Some of these are essential, full-time roles. Others will come and go at various stages in a project, as needed.

  • Team Leader: Responsible for getting the team to go. Sometimes a facilitator. Sometimes the project manager.
  • Facilitator: Usually a Black Belt or Master Black Belt. Coaches the team in Six Sigma practices.
  • Scribe: Records the team activities.
  • Sponsor: Business leader who sponsors the Six Sigma project. Will tend to set project objectives and obtain resources for the team. Often a liaison between the team and senior management.
  • Champion: Executive who sponsors a specific Six Sigma project. Ensures that resources are available. Resolves any cross-functional team issues. (Sometimes this is the same as the sponsor. Different companies use different titles.)
  • Six Sigma Leader: Executive who’s responsible for Six Sigma culture in the company.
  • Process Owner: Person responsible for the business process targeted by a Six Sigma project.
  • Team member: Person who will work on a project. Usually has specific skills that are relevant.
  • Gatekeeper: Audits the deliverables. Checks them against requirements.
  • Management: Provides resources and motivation.

Also see Six Sigma Roles and Responsibilities.

The PDCA cycle, aka ADeming wheel, Shewhart wheel or Shewhart Cycle is a the continuous improvement practice of making a Plan, Performing an action, Checking your results and then Acting upon what you have learned.

Project Planning Tools 

Project planning is one of the critical phases in project management; it comes after the project initiation phase. Project planning describes the objectives or outputs that are expecting from the project to yield.

Work Breakdown Structure: A work breakdown structure is a critical deliverable that organizes the team’s work into a manageable section. In other words, it is a plan which expands the project or statement of work into a detailed listing of activities requires to complete the project.

Program Evaluation and review technique (PERT): PERT chart is a tool that shows the project as a network diagram. It represents events and activities in sequence in the network to determine the critical path. Critical path is the sequence of tasks that requires the greatest expected time.

Critical path method (CPM): CPM is the longest duration through a project network diagram. Moreover, CPM is very similar to PERT; both use overlapping methodologies.

Stakeholder Analysis: We use Stakeholder Analysis to identify people who have a stake in our product. Then we classify those stakeholders to figure out:

  • How to weight their input at various stages.
  • When and how to keep them informed.

Communication Plan: A communication plan is to consciously direct the flow of information about a project. Use a communications plan to ensure that you’re talking to the right people at every stage of your project.

Project Tracking Tools

Organizations need strong project tracking tools to effectively executing the six sigma projects. Project tracking tools are important, because Six Sigma is based around projects. Find a problem, define it, measure it, analyze it, fix it, and then ensure the solution ‘sticks’. If any single phase goes wrong, so does the whole project. Following are the few project tracking tools.

Gantt Chart: A Gantt chart is a project tracking tool. A Gantt chart is a bar chart that represents the duration of task against the progression of time.

RACI Matrix: The most common project responsibility matrix tool that clarifies roles and responsibilities during project execution. It describes the participation by various roles in completing tasks or deliverables. RACI stands for Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, and Informed.

Project priority matrix: A project priority matrix is a project planning tool that helps your team to figure out where to put their strongest efforts.

Analytical Tools

The seven quality tools like check sheets, scatter diagram, histogram, flow charts, Pareto chart, fishbone diagram, stratification were good for data collection analysis. However the new analytical tools allows for identification, planning and coordination in finding a problem solution.

Affinity Diagrams: An affinity diagram is a good technique for identifying & displaying potential root causes for unfamiliar problems. Affinity diagrams help you organize ideas into meaningful categories by recognizing common groupings. This method helps you reduce large amounts of data into a smaller set.

Tree Diagram: A Tree diagram helps you break down big concepts into progressively greater detail. The idea here is to systematically breaking down a concept into its constituent pieces.

Matrix Diagram: Matrix diagram displays relationships within a single group or amongst two, three, or four groups (Ex. project objective, methods, results, causes, people, etc.). It also provides information like the strength of relationship amongst the group, the roles played by various groups,etc.

Prioritization matrix – Prioritization matrix can help you to work out and negotiate priorities for a project. It can also be used to prioritize projects themselves, although opinions are mixed on whether this usage is a good idea.

Activity Network Diagram: The primary intent of creating an Activity Network Diagram is to create a flow chart showing the necessary tasks for a project in sequence order (including parallel and serial paths).

Define Phase Deliverables

  • Identify problem statement
  • Determine the project scope
  • Conduct financial impact
  • Establish project goals and form team
  • Determine project deliverables and milestones
  • Project charter acceptance from management
  • Define phase tollgate review

Important Videos of Define Phase (DMAIC)

Six Sigma Black Belt Certification Define Phase Questions:

Question: Which of the following tools is commonly used in the define phase of a project? (Taken from ASQ sample Black Belt exam.)

(A) Affinity diagram
(B) Control chart
(C) Failure mode and effects analysis
(D) Data collection checklist

Answer:

Unlock Additional Members-only Content!

To unlock additional content, please upgrade now to a full membership.
Upgrade to a Full Membership
If you are a member, you can log in here.

Contributors

Comments (2)

I think you have your proactive and reactive subheadings flipped under Voice of Client. As the examples listed under reactive are actually proactive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.