What is a Cause and Effect Matrix?
A Cause and Effect Matrix is a six sigma tool used to determine the key process input variables (KPIVs) based on priorities of customer outputs (KPOVs). In other words, it reveals the correlation between process input variables to the outputs of the customer during the root cause analysis.
A Cause and Effect Matrix is also called an X-Y diagram, Prioritization Matrix, and Correlation Matrix. The goal of the Cause and Effect Matrix is to mathematically compute the relationship between key process input variables (Xs) and Customer outputs (Ys).
Cause and effect analysis, process flow map, and information about the voice of customer are the prerequisites for a Cause and Effect Matrix.
A Cause and Effect Matrix can be used to examine and document relationships between input and output variables. This method is also very much similar to the Quality Function Deployment. It objectively evaluates the team’s subjective opinions about the KPIVs.
When Would You Use an X-Y Diagram in the DMAIC Process?
The Cause and Effect Matrix is a great tool for prioritizing a long list of possible things and is especially useful in the Measure phase of the DMAIC project. This method is also used to determine the primary factors for experiments in DOE and also to determine the goals of the Matrix Diagram & FMEA.
In a process, the input variables might influence the outcome, but not all input variables are equally important. Hence, you should develop a mathematical model to concentrate the important inputs with respect to the customer’s output. The Cause and Effect Matrix helps to identify such key inputs.
How Do You Use It?
Step 1: First identify the customer requirements, or in other words, understand the voice of the customer. This can be done by conducting surveys, focus groups, and other means to collect their priorities. Place those priorities at the top of the X-Y diagram
Step 2: Assign a priority factor for each of the customer outputs. Generally use a 1-10 scale, with 1 being the low priority and 10 being the high priority to the customer
Step 3: List all possible key input variables or the improvement factors of the process in each row; those are the Xs in the X-Y diagram
Step 4: Assess the relationship between key input variables and the customer outputs, and then rank each input variable accordingly. We recommend using a geometric progression scale (0,1,3 and 9), with 0 being no impact, 1 – low impact, 3 – medium impact, and 9 – strong impact or high correlation on output
Step 5: Cross-multiply the customer output priority numbers with correlation rankings and sum each row at the extreme right column
Step 6: Finally, determine the rank based on the highest sum total and highlight the critical few variables. This will help to identify the improvement areas
An Example of an X-Y Diagram.
XYZ coffee shop franchise located in the San Diego downtown area has reported falling sales for the past 6 months. A Six Sigma team conducts a root cause analysis, and they also want to see the key process inputs that are impacting the process.
- Conducts customer surveys and identifies key customer requirements
- Assigns a priority factor for each of the customer outputs.
- List all possible key input variables
- Assess the relationship between key input variables to the customer outputs and rank each input variable accordingly
- Cross-multiply the customer output priority numbers with correlation rankings and sum each row
- Ex: for coffee flavor = 9*9+3*6+3*3+9*3+1*4 = 139
- Finally, determine the rank based on the highest sum total and highlight the critical few variables.
Benefits of Cause and Effect Matrix
- It helps to include customer inputs for decision making
- Visually depict the correlation between key input variables to the customer outputs
- The priority ranking method helps to take the decision based on the score rather than individual opinions
- Data collection costs may be reduced by ignoring non-key process inputs
- Helps to list all the input variables required for the process
Hi Ted could not find the sixsigma.org website that was in the video. Can you provide the link?
I found the link but it looks like the website was abandoned. Worse yet, the website that is now in its place is entirely infested with ID theft software.
So, I won’t post the link, but I can see what I can do about creating a download similar to what they show here. Is that what you were looking for?
Could you please explain what decision can be made in the Coffee Shop example once you have the ranks?
Are we saying that only the top three will be the focus of the SS project?
Also, what happens when the Xs might not be completely independent? For example, the “beans freshness” affects the “coffee flavour”?
Hello Varun Pai,
The objective of cause and effect matrix is to mathematically compute the correlation between key process input variables (X’s) and Customer outputs (Y’s).
In a process all the input variables might influence the outcome, but all the input variables are not equally important. Hence develop a mathematical model to concentrate the important input variables with respect to the customers output.
There is no hard and fast rule to take only top 3. Based on customer importance, you can consider top priority Xs. It helps to include customer inputs for decision-making.
Basically, priority ranking method helps to take the decision based on score rather than individual opinions.
If any of the Xs are dependent, you can consider both for the implementation of process improvements or corrective actions.
Actually you are not computing the correlation between x and y at all. What you are doing is simply assigning a subjective score to the strength of associativity between x and y.
Thank you for the great example of the X-Y diagram!
Glad it was helpful, Barbara!